This article is adapted from an episode of our podcast, “Civic.” Click the audio player below to hear the full story.


San Francisco once positioned itself as a national leader in protecting residents from government surveillance. In 2019, city lawmakers adopted sweeping restrictions on the use of surveillance technology, including a ban on government use of facial recognition.

“It’s psychologically unhealthy when people know they’re being watched in every aspect of the public realm,” then-Supervisor Aaron Peskin warned.

Just five years later, voters approved a measure allowing police to deploy new surveillance technologies before obtaining approval from the Board of Supervisors.

The reversal reflected a longstanding struggle between public safety demands and civil liberties protections, one shaped by decades of expanding government surveillance and changing political priorities.

In the second installment of “Somebody’s Watching You,” a three-part audio series from the San Francisco Public Press’ “Civic,” we examine how the federal government’s response to the 9/11 terrorist attacks transformed intelligence gathering and how San Francisco participated in that expansion, working alongside the FBI’s Joint Terrorism Task Force.

This episode of “Civic” traces San Francisco’s shifting approach to surveillance since 9/11, examining how a city once at the forefront of privacy protections embraced an expanding network of police cameras, license plate readers and drones, raising new concerns about civil liberties, oversight and control of the data collected.


Meanwhile, advances in digital technology were transforming what government agencies could collect and learn about individuals. Private technology companies developed systems capable of combining enormous amounts of information from previously separate databases. Intelligence agencies could increasingly identify patterns, associations and movements rather than simply investigate individual suspects.

The implications became especially contentious as federal immigration enforcement intensified when Donald Trump took office in 2017. His administration announced a crackdown on sanctuary cities, putting San Francisco’s restrictions on cooperation with federal immigration authorities at odds with the new administration’s priorities.

At a Police Commission hearing in January 2017, Joy Xi of the Asian Law Caucus described how FBI agents had raided her family’s home less than two years earlier after wrongly suspecting her father of espionage. Although the charges were eventually dropped, the experience left the family fearful.

“We lived in fear every day that the FBI may have been listening to our conversations,” Xi told commissioners. “We didn’t feel safe in our own home because we were afraid of surveillance.”

Xi said her family’s experience reflected a broader history of government scrutiny of Chinese Americans dating back to the McCarthy era.

Concerns that local officers working under FBI authority could become involved in investigations inconsistent with San Francisco’s civil-liberties protections prompted the police department to withdraw its officers from the Joint Terrorism Task Force shortly after Trump’s inauguration.

But the city’s own surveillance capabilities continued to grow.

In 2019, privacy advocates secured a major victory with the Stop Secret Surveillance Ordinance. The law required city departments to disclose how surveillance technologies would be used, assess their potential impacts and obtain approval from elected officials.

The protections proved politically vulnerable.

As concerns about crime intensified, then-Mayor London Breed and other proponents of expanded policing powers argued that restrictions on technology were hindering law enforcement.

In March 2024, voters approved Proposition E, easing some of the oversight requirements established five years earlier. The measure allowed police to begin using certain new surveillance technologies before obtaining legislative approval, fundamentally changing the balance between deployment and public scrutiny.

The shift opened the door to a rapid expansion of automated license plate readers, police drones and other surveillance tools.

Privacy advocates warn that the consequences extend beyond whether police can solve more crimes. As surveillance systems become increasingly interconnected, information collected for one purpose can be accessed, combined or used for another, raising fundamental questions about who controls that information, how it might be misused, and what the expansion of surveillance means for privacy and civil liberties.

Sylvie Sturm is an award-winning journalist with 25 years of experience in print, primarily writing and editing for community newspapers in Canada. Since relocating to the Bay Area in 2014, she has focused on audio journalism and currently contributes to the “Civic” podcast from the San Francisco Public Press. She also mentors science writers at University of California, San Francisco in print and podcasting, and has taught media at San Francisco State University.