Imagine you are a senior living on a fixed income. On top of paying rent and a steady Pacific Gas & Electric bill, you pay your landlord nearly $200 a month for other utilities.

Instead of charging for individual usage, your landlord divides costs among all the units — possibly including landscaping and building-wide plumbing issues — using a special formula. Your sewage costs alone can rise to $100 a month, going beyond the 5% limit specified in your lease.

That is the reality for a Parkmerced resident who described the hardships created by an increasingly common billing system in communications to California Attorney General Rob Bonta and the San Francisco City Attorney’s Office.

Ratio utility billing systems, also known as RUBS, are growing in popularity among San Francisco landlords and property managers. These systems can increase financial pressure on tenants in the form of unpredictable, often higher, monthly utility bills.

Because costs are divided across the building, based on factors like apartment square footage, even a tenant who reduces usage can see their bill can go up. Tenants are also left paying higher costs when landlords are slow to complete necessary repairs related to utility usage, such as leaks. But despite increased expenses, tenants rarely receive information to determine if they are being billed properly.

Some landlords are also using non-payment of rent as a pretext to evict tenants who pay rent on time but have fallen behind on utility payments charged by the landlord or a third party that go beyond allowable annual rent increases. Anti-displacement organizers and attorneys say this is illegal. They argue this billing system violates San Francisco’s rent ordinance and are pushing for legislation to regulate or ban this practice.

Charley Goss, government and community affairs manager of the San Francisco Apartment Association, wrote in an email to the Public Press that ratio utility billing systems are legal when included in new tenancy lease agreements.

The San Francisco City Attorney’s Office and the San Francisco Rent Board declined interviews for this story. Jen Kwart, communications director of the City Attorney’s Office, wrote in an email that “RUBS are on our radar, and we encourage any tenants or community organizations aware of systemic illegal practices by landlords to submit a complaint here.”

A Public Press examination of public records found several complaints from tenants who described these systems as unfair and outlined billing disputes with landlords.

Hidden utility bills

Historically, either units were separately metered for gas and electricity usage and tenants paid PG&E directly, or buildings had a shared meter and utilities were included in a tenant’s base rent. However, it is increasingly common for landlords to charge tenants a monthly individualized bill for utilities, based not on the tenant’s usage but on the entire building’s. This can be in addition to PG&E bills that the tenant is responsible for.

Here’s how ratio utility billing systems work: Monthly utility costs, sometimes including common areas, are totaled across the entire building and then split among residents using a special formula. Formulas are determined by the landlord or a third party company used to handle billing, such as Conservice or Anchor Utility. They are often opaque to tenants and can be based on factors like the unit’s number of bedrooms, occupants or square footage.

“The problems that stem from this are astronomical,” said Ora Prochovnick, director of litigation and policy at the Eviction Defense Collaborative, who described these systems as a bait-and-switch for tenants.

Because bills are based on total building usage, charges fluctuate greatly month-to-month, meaning there is little predictability or way for tenants to budget if they want to save money by conserving on utilities.

Molly Goldberg, executive director of the San Francisco Anti-Displacement Coalition, said she has seen tenants go on vacation for a month only to be hit with a utility bill $300 more than it was the month before.

This system is especially difficult for low-income tenants.

“You are really putting at risk housing security for those that can’t deal with that type of volatility,” said Olivia Wein, a senior attorney at the National Consumer Law Center.

Tuesday Rose Thornton, a senior attorney at the Eviction Defense Collaborative, saidratio utility billing systems are a way to increase returns when owners would otherwise be limited by rent control. Landlords’ own rhetoric appears to support this claim.

In a June 2023 publication of the San Francisco Apartment Association, Jay Greenberg, a real estate agent at Compass, cited these systems as a way for landlords to recoup increasing utility costs from tenants. In his experience, getting “the utility bill back is of greater value than any allowable rent increase,” he wrote. He did not respond to requests for comment.

This can reverse efforts to keep housing costs affordable.

Rey has lived in a two-bedroom Tenderloin apartment for close to a year. The Public Press is using a nickname to protect her identity. The main draw of her apartment was low, predictable rent, as the unit is rent-controlled.

Today, she pays around $300 for utilities each month, about 10% of her rent. Her sewage bill can be as high as $75 though she showers at her gym and doesn’t cook at home.

“It seemed kind of insane to me that one has to pay so much,” she said, adding, “I feel like I should be charged for what I’m using.”

Rey isn’t the only person in her building facing unpredictable utility costs.

After a new owner took over last year, they started implementing ratio utility billing for new tenants and existing tenants who might have not paid for utilities before but whose leases had vague language regarding utility charges.

“People saw their utility bills overnight go up $100, $150, or more,” said Peter Miller, a member of Tenants and Neighborhood Councils, which has been working with tenants in Rey’s building.

Even two-digit increases in bills affect families in the building, Rey said.

Rising evictions and legal challenges

On top of bigger utility bills, increasingly tenants who pay rent on time are being evicted for falling behind on utility payments to their landlords, attorneys and advocates said.

Some evictions are due to breach of a lease agreement but others are for alleged nonpayment of rent.

For the latter, landlords are using a loophole to evict existing tenants and rent units out to new tenants who will pay more, Goldberg said.

If someone has not specified that a payment is for rent, landlords can apply it to other outstanding expenses, including utility charges, before rent. Then they can claim the tenant is behind on rent and file an eviction notice.

“We see these are most often concentrated in long-term tenants, often who are paying well below market in rent-controlled units,” she added.

A woman with short brown hair speaks into a microphone in the foreground. In the background, people hold colorful signs.
Tenants are organizing across the city to fight unfair evictions and poor living conditions. Molly Goldberg spoke at an Oct. 5 rally in support of tenants at 907 Valencia St., who have been on rent strike for over eight months trying to get needed repairs. Credit: Neal Wong / San Francisco Public Press

The legality of using ratio utility billing systems for tenants in rent-controlled units is questionable. Multiple eviction defense attorneys said these systems violate rent control laws because utility costs paid to the landlord fluctuate beyond the annual rent increase limits set by the Rent Board. Thornton said the Eviction Defense Collaborative has successfully challenged several such evictions.

Environmental questions and profiteering

Many landlords use environmental arguments for making tenants pay for utilities, arguing it encourages residents to conserve since they are footing the bill.

“RUBS is a useful tool that boosts conservation and reduces excessive or wasteful utility usage,” wrote Goss with the San Francisco Apartments Association.  

However, critics of how landlords use these systems dispute that rationale because tenants are not billed by how much they individually use and thus have no reason to conserve.

In fact, this billing system may disincentivize landlords from making quick repairs that would benefit the environment, Wein said, because if there are inefficient appliances or plumbing leaks that increase utility bills, tenants bear the cost. “The landlord is shielded from their failure to maintain the property.”

Another challenge is that it is nearly impossible for a tenant to determine whether their bill is accurate or if their landlord is illegally overcharging them. Businesses providing essential services such as water are typically prohibited from turning a profit on those services, Wein said. When bills are split this way, it’s very hard for tenants to understand if that’s happening since “the landlord holds all the cards.”

In addition to seeing the landlord’s utility bills, a tenant would need to understand the formula for how they are being charged and be able to compare their bill to all other residents’ bills. So, she said, “For the tenant, it’s uphill all the way.”

Tenants and legislators fight back

Tenants, eviction defense attorneys and organizers are trying to turn the tide. Anti-displacement advocates said there are several ways to combat unfair utility bills and evictions, pointing to strategies from a tenant union in a Los Angeles apartment building.

Beginning in June 2025, the Virgil Square Tenants Association refused to pay these utility bills until their landlord offered an accurate accounting of building-wide utility costs that were being split among residents. In August 2025, the real estate investment trust that owns the building offered to cut utility bills, but to this day won’t provide tenants with documentation of the underlying costs.

“To me, that’s a pretty damning indication that there’s some — excuse my language — but some f–kery going around with this,” Thornton said, noting that she has yet to see a landlord provide aggregate bills and an explanation for how they are being split.

Given the dangers to tenants, Wein said, ratio utility billing systems should not be allowed. “There is so much unfairness in the design of this mechanism, and there is so much difficulty with accountability.”

The Virgil Square tenants are working to get this utility-billing system banned across LA. It has been severely limited or outlawed in Bay Area cities that have rent control, including Berkeley, Alameda, Mountain View and Oakland.

Attorney General Bonta has challenged these systems at the state level. His office sued Greystar, a national property management firm, alleging it used new utility bills to increase rents beyond what the state allows annually. They reached a nearly $500,000 settlement in 2025.

The local situation is evolving. In October, the San Francisco Board of Supervisors passed a law that prevents landlords from evicting tenants who owe less than one month of fair-market value rent, which Mayor Daniel Lurie signed the same month. District 7 Supervisor Myrna Melgar’s office is working on legislation to more closely regulate these systems.

San Francisco residents are also organizing to address high utility bills and other issues.

 “The tenants who are joining associations and fighting back are winning,” Goldberg said at the Oct. 5 rally. “This San Francisco is going to be one that is shaped by all of us.”

Madison Alvarado is a reporter based in San Francisco who is interested in California's housing crisis, environmental justice and structural inequities. In addition to her reporting on public housing and rent relief at the Public Press, she has covered issues related to the coronavirus pandemic, housing and city government for San Francisco news site Mission Local.